关于FC1有序混乱专长的一点讨论

[frozenmist013]

在之前查资源的时候，顺便看了FC1有序混乱的原文，然后发现一点很奇妙的事情
点了这个专长的角色在决定法术和效应时视为混乱角色
但是给的范例里，直接用这个专长无视了原魔斗篷的混乱阵营前置
也就是说这个专长可以满足专长的混乱阵营要求
那么问题来了，它对进阶和基础职业的阵营要求生效吗
比如守序角色点完这个能不能直接兼蛮子

[Tekkaman Last]

ORDERED CHAOS
You are an unusually lawful
Abyssal heritor.
Prerequisite: Nonchaotic alignment,
base Will save +4.
Benefi t: Your alignment is not affected by
the Abyssal heritor feats
you possess. Spells and
effects that are keyed to
alignment affect you as if you were
chaotic, as well as your actual alignment. For example, you become
immune to spells such as chaos hammer and word of chaos, you
could wield an anarchic weapon without fear of gaining a
negative level, and you could take the Primordial Scion feat
despite its chaotic alignment prerequisite.


我倾向于相当于获得了一个混乱亚种。


但是野蛮人的问题在于，野蛮人并不是必须混乱，野蛮人失去狂暴的原因是变得守序，而不是不再混乱，你就算视为混乱阵营不影响你同时是守序阵营。

[利亚顿弥赛尔]

ORDERED CHAOS
You are an unusually lawful
Abyssal heritor.
Prerequisite: Nonchaotic alignment,
base Will save +4.
Benefi t: Your alignment is not affected by
the Abyssal heritor feats
you possess. Spells and
effects that are keyed to
alignment affect you as if you were
chaotic, as well as your actual alignment. For example, you become
immune to spells such as chaos hammer and word of chaos, you
could wield an anarchic weapon without fear of gaining a
negative level, and you could take the Primordial Scion feat
despite its chaotic alignment prerequisite.


我倾向于相当于获得了一个混乱亚种。


但是野蛮人的问题在于，野蛮人并不是必须混乱，野蛮人失去狂暴的原因是变得守序，而不是不再混乱，你就算视为混乱阵营不影响你同时是守序阵营。

我同意视为混乱亚种，但我觉得这既然是角色后天自愿获得这个专长，那么ta理应将自己的阵营偏向混乱。不然感觉有点身在曹营心在汉。所以我的理解是类似正义之怒的游戏抉择，它会让你本角色的阵营偏向上偏向混乱，当然这个要看dm判你有没有阵营变化。如果dm判你阵营不变或者没变到混乱，应该不能对职业生效

[Tekkaman Last]

真要偏向混乱何必拿这个专长，直接到混乱阵营就完事了。正义之怒那个设定又不是什么好设定，问题一大堆，还是别参考了。